For the Love of a Rose

For The Love of a Rose

This article was originally published on on March 13, 2016. It is reprinted here with the author’s permission.

by Tim Gaiser, MS 

August 2007: I’m in Germany for the Grosse Lage tasting in Wiesbaden with a group of writers and other industry people from the UK and the US. If not familiar, the Grosse Lage classification, which is comprised of the Grosses Gewächs wines, is the pinnacle of Germany’s top dry wines from its best vineyard sites. These wines can only be produced by members of the VDP, or Verband Deutscher Prädikatsweingüter, Germany’s top quality growers association. The VDP is arguably the greatest organization of its kind on the planet. Of the 10,000-plus entities making wine in Germany its membership averages just 200. The VDP is a small and very political club. Every year members are added—and voted off the island.

After the two-day VDP tasting our group was treated to a day-plus of winery tours and tastings. Now it was the last day of the tour and the group was at the final stop; Max Wittmann in the Rheinhessen not far from Mainz. Wittmann makes superb dry Rieslings, especially his GG wine from the Morstein vineyard. It’s racy, intense, and laser-focused with shameless minerality and shocking acidity. I’ve known the Wittmann wines for a long time and was really looking forward to meeting him. But the rest of the group—not so much. It’s the end of the tour. Mind you, we’ve only been in the country for four days but in the heat and humidity (yes, Germany can have both in late summer) the group of otherwise august professionals has begun to melt down.

Max takes us through the winery and we taste the new vintage just bottled. Each wine was like experiencing a small dose of delicious electric shock. After the tour everyone heads outside to a lunch of sandwiches and Riesling. Not a bad combination. The group hoovers the sandwiches all the while complaining about the heat and humidity—even the sandwiches. At that point I wandered off to check out the grounds. The first thing I spotted were the guardians of the cellar perched high on a pole and covered in cobwebs just outside the cellar door. They’ve been featured previously in two separate posts (see photo below).


A few steps further and I stumble across what has to be the most enormous—and beautiful–rose garden I’ve ever seen; easily half an acre of the most gorgeous roses of every color and kind. To be honest, I should say that I was assaulted by a tsunami of rose floral long before I turned a corner and actually spotted the source. I spent the next half hour going through the garden taking photographs and smelling the roses, as they say.

I have lots of favorite smells/aromas but there is one far above all else—a rose. Not just any rose and definitely not the roses you buy at Trader Joe’s or Safeway because you completely spaced out your girlfriend/wife’s birthday or your anniversary. Nyet. A true heirloom rose. To me an heirloom rose is perfection. It’s the zillions-to-one against all odds when somehow some way countless molecules assemble themselves into a sublimely beautiful form that smells even more sublimelier. So much for good English.

The aromatics of an heirloom rose to me aren’t simply “floral” as with other kinds of flowers; they have an arc or a curve, almost like a musical chord with brighter, higher aromatics, fruitier middle notes, and earthy low tones. Internally for me there’s also a color gradation to the curve going from lighter hues at the top gradually down to deeper hues at the bottom. The color range changes depending on the actual rose. I experience pepper and certain other aromas the same way.

For Love of a Rose Yellow

Hardware: How do We Physically Smell?

As you can easily tell by now I find the aroma of an heirloom rose to be transcendent. No surprise then that my time in the Wittman rose garden instantly became a formative olfactory memory. But how is it we’re able to smell anything at all? What’s the apparatus for detecting all things olfactory? Thinking back to that beautiful rose garden at Wittman, when I smelled one of the roses the odor molecules traveled up my nasal cavity to behind the bridge of my nose where they were absorbed by very unique receptor cells. These cells have microscopic hairs called cilia. There are some five million of these olfactory cells that constantly fire up impulses to the brain’s olfactory center.

Further, these olfactory regions in the upper nasal cavity are moist, yellow regions of fatty substances found at the upper reaches of each nostril. When the olfactory bulb detects an aroma it sends a signal to the cerebral cortex, a message directly into the limbic system–one of the most ancient parts of the brain. Unlike the other four senses, there is no editing or filtering our response to an aroma and thus the reason why our smell memories can be so incredibly vivid and powerful.

Software: the Anatomy of a Smell Memory

All this is well and good but how do we recognize an aroma? And for that matter, how do we remember what something smells like? I’ve written about both extensively over the last five years-plus in various pieces in this blog and elsewhere. All are related to my tasting project which dates back to late 2009 and two film sessions I did with a behavioral scientist, Tim Hallbom. Perhaps the most simple yet utterly profound thing Tim and I discovered during those sessions was that smell memory is visual internally; that the aromas I recognized in a glass of wine were represented by internal visual images—images which up that point in time I was completely unaware I was creating. These images were/are taken from my life memories of the various aromatics I smell in the glass, be they various fruits, spices, earth tones or whatever. A second discovery followed quickly; that these internal images I generated to represent the aromas in a given wine displayed all sorts of structural qualities, from size to brightness to proximity to dimensionality. And if I changed any of a handful of the most important qualities my perception of the wine changed as well.

The Feeling Factor

In the years following those initial film sessions I’ve confirmed the olfactory-image connection with practically every wine professional I’ve ever interviewed with precious few exceptions. But are pictures and movies enough to create a profound smell memory? Probably not. Like a favorite movie, song, or person, strong feelings are also involved in that you care about said movie, song, or person; you probably like—even love–it/them and can instantly recognize them in an instant much less bring up a complete memory just as quickly.

When I think back to that rose garden or any of my favorite smell memories my experience is not just visual. It’s a rich tapestry that always involves multiple senses. Perhaps a profound smell memory is the confluence of strong neuro-association, literally a point in time when sight, smell, auditory, and kinesthetic collide to crystalize a moment. If I step back into my rose garden memory I can almost instantly feel the heat and humidity of early afternoon on my skin and the sun on my face. I can hear the drone of my colleagues conversing in the distance as well as the sound of bees buzzing around me. As I lean forward to smell a given rose I remember closing my eyes to focus on the aromatics. At that moment there’s also an internal feeling of reaching forward or out to something. Finally—and arguably as important as any of the components of my memory—there’s also the most amazing feeling when I actually smell the rose, something for me that’s akin to being in the presence of a beautiful painting, seeing a gorgeous sunset, or hearing a great piece of music. Without going completely Marin County on you, it’s like being in the presence of beauty and source however you define it. For me any such experience is always accompanied by a feeling a gratitude if only for just having a chance be here and play the game.

What I take away from the rose garden memory is not only how incredible the roses smelled on that day at that time—but how the experience made me feel. That’s probably why I can call up a complete IMAX memory of that rose garden in a micro-second and why I can also detect “rose” in the top note of any wine almost as quickly.

For Love of a Rose Red

In the end, I would venture to say that my love of roses and how they smell is a useful barometer of how important olfactory is to me not only as a professional but personally as well. As someone whose career is based on olfactory it’s all about the desire to remember how things smell as well as how important it is to care about olfactory memory in the first place. How our most powerful olfactory and wine memories make us feel may be one of the most profound things we experience as wine professionals. I wouldn’t have it any other way.

À votre santé!


SommDay School



Cancellations of confirmed in-person course enrollments and workshops are accepted up to 60 days before the start of the course. An administration fee of $50 plus the full cost of the study materials and exam fees will be deducted, and the remainder of the course fee refunded to the payee. Separate WSET exam cancellation/transfer rules apply.
Transfers of a confirmed enrollment to another course are accepted 60 days before the course start date with an administration fee of $50.

Cancellations less than 60 days before the in-person course start date or course no shows forfeit any refund/transfer options unless students can provide medical documentation. If medical documentation is provided, students can be transferred to a later course. No refunds will be applied.

Course Transfers cannot be carried forward to the next academic year (which commenced on January 1).

Students are highly encouraged to purchase separate travel insurance.

You've got this!

Flamingo Hotel Las Vegas

Your WSET Level 3 exam will take place on

February 12, 2023 at 10:00 AM (Pacific)


3555 Las Vegas Blvd

Las Vegas, NV 89109


You've got this!

Mariott Santa Ynez

Your WSET Level 3 exam will take place on

April 23, 2023 at 10:00 AM (Pacific)


555 McMurray Road

Buelton, CA 93427


You've got this!

Art Hotel Denver

Your WSET Level 3 exam will take place on

March 5, 2023 at 10:00 AM (Mountain)


1201 Broadway

Denver, CO 80203


You've got this!

Aloft Nashville

Your WSET Level 3 exam will take place on

February 12, 2023 at 10:00 AM (Central)


1719 West End Ave.

Nashville, TN 37203


You've got this!

Epicurean Hotel

Your WSET Level 3 exam will take place on

March 19, 2023 at 10:00 AM (Eastern)


1207 S Howard Ave,

Tampa, FL 33606


You've got this!

Street View of HQ

Your WSET Level 3 exam will take place on

January 22, 2023 at 10:00 AM (Pacific)


2501 Oak Street

Napa, CA 94559